Horizontal Convection and Ocean Energy Balances

William Young

Scripps Institution of Oceanography
UC San Diego

Abstract-
As a basic model relevant to ocean circulation I'll discuss "horizontal convection": a Boussinesq fluid forced by applying a non-uniform temperature at its top surface, with all other boundaries insulating. I'll prove that if the viscosity and thermal diffusivity are lowered to zero the mechanical energy dissipation per unit mass also vanishes. Thus, according to some religious definitions of turbulence, this form of convection can never become truly turbulent (even though the Rayleigh and Reynolds' numbers are very large). Despite this 'anti-turbulence theorem', horizontal convection exhibits a transition from a steady to an eddying flow which is controlled by the Rayleigh and Prandtl numbers. I'll briefly review the related problem of Rayleigh-Benard convection in which experimental evidence indicates that the energy dissipation per mass again vanishes in the inviscid limit.

The implications of these results is that the global ocean circulation is energetically sustained by winds and tides, rather than the pole-to-equator surface density gradient. Thus the ocean is not a heat engine. Rather the ocean is a mechanically driven conveyor belt, transporting heat and freshwater almost as passive contaminants. The engine of the conveyor belt is powered by tides and wind stress. With uncertain consequences, climate models ignore this physics, or sweep it into prescribed eddy diffusivities.


GALCIT Home Page
2002-2003 Fluids Seminar Page


Maintained by: Michael Johnson
EMail: Michael Johnson
Last modified: September 10, 2002